Why am I receiving SHCNE_UPDATE­DIR notifications that my code never generates?

Raymond Chen

A customer had created a custom shell namespace, and they generated notifications for items in that namespace. Meanwhile, they also had code that listened for those notifications, and they found that sometimes the listener received SHCNE_UPDATE­DIR notifications, which is odd because their namespace never generates those notifications. So where did they come from?

The shell change notification system will sometimes coalesce notifications. It typically does this to avoid flooding the notification system.

The customer wanted to know if coalescing was more likely to happen when the notifications are generated at high frequency. They found that the behavior varied from system to system. Some of them were seeing the SHCNE_UPDATE­DIR, and others weren’t.

Yes, the rate of notification generation is a factor. If you quickly generate a hundred SHCNE_UPDATE­ITEM notifications for items all within the same folder, the shell change notification system is probably going to replace them all with a single SHCNE_UPDATE­DIR notification. The likelihood of coalescing also increases if the recipient is slow to process the notifications.

In such cases, the shell replaces the separate “item 1 changed”, “item 2 changed”, “item 3 changed” notifications with a single SHCNE_UPDATE­DIR, which means “There were changes to this folder.” This reduces the amount of notification traffic, reduces the memory needed to keep track of those notifications, and hopefully improves performance on the clients, since they can just refresh the whole folder instead of churning through hundreds of tiny little notifications.

1 comment

Discussion is closed. Login to edit/delete existing comments.

  • switchdesktopwithfade@hotmail.com 0

    When explorer.exe isn’t running as the taskbar shell, all shell namespace updates cease because the taskbar unnecessarily hosts the relayer. I would rather get spammed than have nothing at all. Every file manager window just sits there without the updates, unless we wire up ReadDirectoryChangesW and a bunch of other functions too but then we’re just recreating the namespace.

Feedback usabilla icon