Don't be helpless: I don't know anything about MFC modal loops, but unlike some people, I'm not afraid to find out

Raymond Chen


Commenter Tom Grelinger asks via the Suggestion Box

If I have a modal CDialog that is visible and usable to the user.
Let’s say I receive an event somewhere else in the program
and I call DestroyWindow on the modal CDialog from within the event.
I notice that the OnDestroy is called on the CDialog,
but DoModal never exits until a WM_QUIT is posted to the modal’s message pump.
What are the pitfalls to this?
Unfortunately, there is really no way to avoid this situation.

I’m not sure what the question is, actually.
The question as stated is “What are the pitfalls to this?”
but he answered that in his own question:
The pitfall is that “DoModal never exits until a WM_QUIT is
posted to the modal dialog’s message pump.”

I’m going to assume that the question really is,
“Why doesn’t destroying the window work?”
with the follow-up question,
“What is the correct way to dismiss a modal dialog?”

The first problem with this question is that it assumes that I know
what a CDialog is.
From its name, I’m going to assume that this
is an MFC class for managing a dialog box.
But you don’t even have to know that to answer the first
reformulated question operating only from Win32 principles:
DestroyWindow is not how you exit a modal dialog.
You exit a modal dialog with EndDialog.
The DestroyWindow technique is for modeless

But let’s look at the question another way,
which is my point for today:
You have the MFC source code.
Don’t be afraid to read it.
Especially since I don’t use MFC personally;
I don’t even know the basic principles of application design with MFC.
I work in straight Win32.
As a result,
I don’t know the answer off the top of my
head, but fifteen minutes reading the MFC source code quickly reveals
the reason why destroying the window doesn’t work.

Watch me as I go and find out the answer.
It’s nothing you can’t already do yourself.

CDialog::DoModal method
calls CWnd::RunModalLoop to run the dialog loop.
If you look at CWnd::RunModalLoop,
you can see the conditions under which it will exit the modal loop.
Here’s the code with irrelevant details deleted.
(They’re irrelevant because they have nothing to do with how the
modal loop exits.)

int CWnd::RunModalLoop(DWORD dwFlags)
    ... preparatory work ...
    // acquire and dispatch messages until the modal state is done
    for (;;)
        ... code that doesn't break out of the loop ...
        // phase2: pump messages while available
            // pump message, but quit on WM_QUIT
            if (!AfxGetThread()->PumpMessage())
                return -1;
            ... other code that doesn't break out of the loop ...
            if (!ContinueModal())
                goto ExitModal;
            ... other code that doesn't break the loop ...
        }  while (::PeekMessage(pMsg, NULL, NULL, NULL, PM_NOREMOVE))
    return m_nModalResult;

There are only two ways out of this loop.
The first is the receipt of a WM_QUIT message.
The second is if CWnd::ContinueModal decides that
the modal loop is finished.
The commenter already mentioned the quit message aspect to the
modal loop, so that just leaves CWnd::ContinueModal.

The CWnd::ContinueModal method is very simple:

BOOL CWnd::ContinueModal()
    return m_nFlags & WF_CONTINUEMODAL;

Therefore, the only other way the loop can exit is if somebody
clears the WF_CONTINUEMODAL flag.
A little grepping shows that there are only three places where this
flag is cleared.
One is in CPropertyPage, which is a derived class
of CDialog and therefore isn’t relevant here.
(I’ll ignore CPropertyPage in future searches.)
The second is in the line above right after the label
And the third is this method:

void CWnd::EndModalLoop(int nResult)
    // this result will be returned from CWnd::RunModalLoop
    m_nModalResult = nResult;
    // make sure a message goes through to exit the modal loop
    if (m_nFlags & WF_CONTINUEMODAL)
        m_nFlags &= ~WF_CONTINUEMODAL;

This method is called in only one place:

void CDialog::EndDialog(int nResult)
    ::EndDialog(m_hWnd, nResult);

Following the money one last step,
the CDialog::EndDialog method is called
from four places in CDialog.
It’s called from CDialog::HandleInitDialog and
CDialog::InitDialog if some catastrophic error
occurs during dialog initialization.
And it's called from CDialog::OnOK
and CDialog::OnCancel in response to the
user clicking the OK or Cancel buttons.

Notice that the CDialog::EndDialog method is not
called when somebody forcibly destroys the dialog from
the outside.

That's why destroying the dialog window doesn't break the modal loop.
If you want to break out of the modal loop, your only choices are
to post a quit message or call CWnd::EndModalLoop,
either directly or indirectly (via CDialog::EndDialog,
for example).

Notice that the MFC modal loop obeys the convention on quit messages
by re-posting the quit message when it breaks out of the modal loop.
(Though it really should have posted the wParam from
the quit message rather than just posting zero.)

The workaround therefore is not to destroy the dialog with
DestroyWindow (something you should have known
not to do a priori since that's not how you exit
modal dialog boxes) but rather by calling
CDialog::EndDialog, passing a result code that
lets the caller of CDialog::DoModal know that
the dialog box exited under unusual circumstances.

This took me fifteen minutes to research and a little over an hour to
write up.
All this work to answer a question that you should have been able
to answer yourself with a little elbow grease.
You're a smart person.
Have confidence in yourself.
You can do it.
I know you can.

Raymond Chen
Raymond Chen

Follow Raymond