The wrong way to check whether the mouse buttons have been swapped

Raymond Chen


Back in the late 1990’s, the window manager team received a bug
that said that sometimes the mouse button state
got messed up and the computer acted
as if the buttons were stuck down.
Further investigation revealed that it occurred only when one
particular program was running, and only if the user had enabled mouse
button swapping.

The reason is that the program in question detected whether the
mouse buttons were swapped with a function like this:

// do not use this function
BOOL AreMouseButtonsSwapped()
 BOOL fWasSwapped = SwapMouseButton(FALSE);
 if (fWasSwapped) SwapMouseButton(TRUE);
 return fWasSwapped;

The SwapMouseButton function changes the button swap state
and returns the old state.
The way the program checked whether the buttons were swapped
was by unswapping the buttons and using the return value to
determine what the previous setting was,
then re-swapping the buttons if the previous setting was
“Yes, they were swapped.”

If you started with the buttons swapped, running this function
created a tiny window where the buttons were momentarily unswapped.
And if you were unlucky enough to click the mouse during this
window of vulnerability, the program saw one mouse button go down
and a different button come up!
Even though it was the same physical button each time,
it was a different logical button, since the meanings of the buttons
had changed.

The correct way of detecting whether mouse buttons are swapped
is just to ask non-intrusively.

BOOL AreMouseButtonsSwapped()
 return GetSystemMetrics(SM_SWAPBUTTON);
Raymond Chen
Raymond Chen

Follow Raymond