Are SetProp and RemoveProp thread-safe?

Raymond Chen

Raymond

A customer wanted to know whether the Set­Prop and Remove­Prop functions are thread-safe with respect to a specific window and property. “It seems to work under the debugger, but that doesn’t prove that it always will work.”

It depends on what you mean by “thread-safe”. If you have two threads which call Set­Prop or Remove­Prop without synchronization between them, then each individual call will be atomic. For example, two non-synchronized calls to Set­Prop will result in the final property being one value or the other, not a mix of the two values.

On the other hand, you cannot predict what order the operations were ultimately performed. All that is guaranteed is that the result will be consistent with some ordering of the operations.

For example, suppose you have a window and a property whose initial value is 1. One thread calls Set­Prop(hwnd, 2) and the other calls Remove­Prop(hwnd). There are two possible outcomes:

Outcome 1Outcome 2
Property value is 1Property value is 1
SetProp(hwnd, 2);Changes property to 2RemoveProp(hwnd);Property is removed
Returns 1 (removed value)
RemoveProp(hwnd);Property is removed
Returns 2 (removed value)
SetProp(hwnd, 2);Changes property to 2
Property is removedProperty value is 2

The customer seemed satisfied with this answer.

Note that only the individual call to Set­Prop or Remove­Prop is atomic. If you make multiple calls in succession, you cannot guarantee that another thread won’t sneak in between your calls and mess with the property.

Next time, a follow-up question that was never asked.

Raymond Chen
Raymond Chen

Follow Raymond   

0 comments

Comments are closed.