Using WM_COPYDATA to marshal message parameters since the window manager otherwise doesn't know how

Raymond

Miral asks for

the recommended way of passing messages across processes
if they require custom marshaling.

There is no one recommended way of doing the custom marshaling,
although some are hackier than others.

Probably the most architecturally beautiful way of doing
it is to use a mechanism that does perform automatic
marshaling,
like COM and MIDL.
Okay, it’s not actually automatic, but it does allow you just
give MIDL your structures and some information about

how they should be interpreted,
and the MIDL compiler autogenerates the marshaler.
You can then pass the data back and forth by simply
invoking COM methods and letting COM do the work.

Architecturally beautiful often turns into
forcing me to learn more than I really wanted to learn,
so here’s a more self-contained approach:
Take advantage of the
WM_COPY­DATA message.
This is sort of the poor-man’s marshaler.
All it knows how to marshal is a blob of bytes.
It’s your responsibility to take what you want to marshal
and serialize it into a blob of bytes.
WM_COPY­DATA will get the bytes to the other side,
and then the recipient needs to deserialize the blob of bytes
back into your data.
But at least WM_COPY­DATA does the tricky bit
of getting the bytes from one side to the other.

Let’s start with our

scratch program
and have it transfer data to another copy of itself.
Make the following changes:

#include <strsafe.h>
HWND g_hwndOther;
#define CDSCODE_WINDOWPOS 42 // lpData -> WINDOWPOS
void OnWindowPosChanged(HWND hwnd, LPWINDOWPOS pwp)
{
 if (g_hwndOther) {
  COPYDATASTRUCT cds;
  cds.dwData = CDSCODE_WINDOWPOS;
  cds.cbData = sizeof(WINDOWPOS);
  cds.lpData = pwp;
  SendMessage(g_hwndOther, WM_COPYDATA,
           reinterpret_cast<WPARAM>(hwnd),
           reinterpret_cast<LPARAM>(&cds));
 }
 FORWARD_WM_WINDOWPOSCHANGED(hwnd, pwp, DefWindowProc);
}
void OnCopyData(HWND hwnd, HWND hwndFrom, PCOPYDATASTRUCT pcds)
{
 switch (pcds->dwData) {
 case CDSCODE_WINDOWPOS:
  if (pcds->cbData == sizeof(WINDOWPOS)) {
   LPWINDOWPOS pwp = static_cast<LPWINDOWPOS>(pcds->lpData);
   TCHAR szMessage[256];
   StringCchPrintf(szMessage, 256,
    TEXT("From window %p: x=%d, y=%d, cx=%d, cy=%d, flags=%s %s"),
    hwndFrom, pwp->x, pwp->y, pwp->cx, pwp->cy,
    (pwp->flags & SWP_NOMOVE) ? TEXT("nomove") : TEXT("move"),
    (pwp->flags & SWP_NOSIZE) ? TEXT("nosize") : TEXT("size"));
   SetWindowText(hwnd, szMessage);
  }
  break;
 }
}
// WndProc
    HANDLE_MSG(hwnd, WM_WINDOWPOSCHANGED, OnWindowPosChanged);
    HANDLE_MSG(hwnd, WM_COPYDATA, OnCopyData);
// WinMain
    // If there is another window called "Scratch", then it becomes
    // our recipient.
    g_hwndOther = FindWindow(TEXT("Scratch"), TEXT("Scratch"));
    hwnd = CreateWindow(
        "Scratch",                      /* Class Name */
        g_hwndOther ? TEXT("Sender") : TEXT("Scratch"),
        WS_OVERLAPPEDWINDOW,            /* Style */
        CW_USEDEFAULT, CW_USEDEFAULT,   /* Position */
        CW_USEDEFAULT, CW_USEDEFAULT,   /* Size */
        NULL,                           /* Parent */
        NULL,                           /* No menu */
        hinst,                          /* Instance */
        0);                             /* No special parameters */

Just to make it easier to tell the two windows apart,
I call the one sending the message “Sender”.
(Note that my method for finding the other window is
pretty rudimentary, because that’s not the point of
the example.)

Whenever the sender window receives a
WM_WINDOW­POS­CHANGED message,
it sends a copy of the WINDOW­POS structure
to the recipient, which then displays it in its own title bar.
Things to observe:

• The value you put into dwData can be anything
  you like. It’s just another DWORD of data.
  Traditionally, it’s used like a “message number”,
  used to communicate what type of data is being sent.
  In our case, we choose 42 to mean “The lpData points to
  a WINDOW­POS structure.”

• The cbData is the number of bytes you want
  to send, and lpData points to the buffer.
  In our case, the number of bytes is always the same,
  but variable-sized data is also fine.

• The lpData can point anywhere,
  as long as the memory is valid for the lifetime of the
  Send­Message call.
  In this case, I just point it at the data given to me
  by the window manager.
  Of course, if you allocated memory to put into
  lpData, then the responsibility for freeing
  it also belongs to you.

• For safety’s sake, I validate that when I get a
  CDS­CODE_WINDOW­POS request,
  the associated data really is the size of a WINDOW­POS
  structure.
  This helps protect against a rogue caller who tries to crash
  the application by sending a
  CDS­CODE_WINDOW­POS
  with a size less than sizeof(WINDOW­POS), thereby
  triggering a buffer overflow.
  (Exercise: Under what other conditions can the size
  be incorrect?
  How would you fix that?)

• The WM_COPY­DATA copies data in only one direction.
  It does not provide a way to pass information back to the sender.
  (Exercise: How would you pass information back?)

• The hwndFrom parameter is a courtesy
  parameter, like dwData.
  There is currently no attempt to verify that the window
  really is that of the sender.
  (In practice, all that could really be verified is that the
  window belongs to the thread that is doing the sending,
  but right now, not even that level of validation is performed.)

The WM_COPY­DATA message is suitable for
small-to-medium-sized amounts of memory.
Though if the amount of memory is so small that it fits
into a WPARAM and LPARAM,
then even WM_COPY­DATA is overkill.

If you’re going to be passing large chunks of memory,
then you may want to consider

using a shared memory handle instead.
The shared memory handle also has the benefit of being shared,
which means that the recipient can modify the shared memory block,
and the sender can see the changes.
(Yes,
this is one answer to the second exercise,
but see if you can find another answer that tays within the spirit
of the exercise.)

Raymond Chen

Follow