Modality, part 9: Setting the correct owner for modal UI, practical exam

Raymond Chen


Here’s a question that came from a customer.
You can answer it yourself based on what you know about modal UI.
(If you’re kind of rusty on the topic,

you can catch up here
I’ve left in some irrelevant details
just to make things interesting.

Our program launches a helper program
to display an Aero Wizard
to guide the user through submitting a service request.


There are no EnableWindow calls leading up to
or returning from this call.
the DoModal handles things nicely.

When the user clicks “Cancel” to cancel the service request,
we use a TaskDialog so we can get the new look for our confirmation
message box.
The task dialog setup goes like this:

TASKDIALOGCONFIG config = { 0 };
config.cbSize = sizeof(config);
config.hwndParent = hwndMainFrame;

When the user clicks “Yes” to cancel,
then another window instead of our frame becomes active.

On a hunch, I replaced the task dialog with a Win32 message box

MessageBox(hwndMainFrame, ...);

and bingo, we get the correct behavior.
When our wizard exits, the main frame receives focus.

I believe that the “automatic” modal behavior that comes
with DoModal() that takes care of disabling
and reenabling the main frame is somehow getting short-circuited
by using TaskDialog from inside our
PSM_QUERYCANCEL message handler.

Right now, we’ve switched to MessageBox,
but we would much prefer to use the task dialog.

Although it’s not common,
it is legal to have a window’s parent or owner
belongs to another thread or process.
But it definitely makes things a bit more tricky to manage
because it attaches the input queues of the two threads,
and you now have two threads coöperating to manage a single
window hierarchy.

Is the cross-process window hierarchy a contributing factor
to the problem, or is it just a red herring?

Raymond Chen
Raymond Chen

Follow Raymond   


Comments are closed.