Enable repeatable package restores using a lock file

Anand Gaurav

Anand

With PackageReference, NuGet always tries to produce the same closure of package dependencies if the input package reference list has not changed. However, there are a few scenarios where it may not be able to do so. While these cases are limited, we received multiple requests to completely lock down the full package dependency graph for projects to produce repeatable restores (builds). We have been working on your feedback, iterating quite a few times, on the approach and design over the past few months. We are happy to announce that we have now introduced the ability to lock your project’s package dependency graph via a lock file – packages.lock.json. With this feature, NuGet uses the lock file to restore packages for PackageReference based projects. This file should be checked into your source code repository. If present during restore, and if the input package references does not change for a given project, NuGet now uses the lock file to determine the dependencies instead of re-evaluating the package graph. Depending on your scenario, you can configure NuGet to either overwrite the lock file (default) or to fail the restore operation whenever the package graph changes.

Which versions of NuGet support restore with lock file?

The lock file functionality is available with the following NuGet distributions:

Why use a lock file?

There are a few cases where NuGet may not be able to get the same package graph with every restore across machines. Most of these cases happen when consumers or repositories do not follow NuGet best practices. For example:

  1. nuget.config mismatch: This may lead to an inconsistent set of package repositories (or sources) across restores. Based on the packages’ version availability on these repositories, NuGet may end up resolving to different versions of the packages upon restore.

  2. Intermediate versions: A missing version of the package, matching PackageReference version requirements, is published: * Day 1: If you specified <PackageReference Include="My.Sample.Lib" Version="4.0.0"/> but the versions available on the NuGet repositories were 4.1.0, 4.2.0 and 4.3.0, NuGet resolves to 4.1.0 as it the nearest minimum version. * Day 2: Version 4.0.0 gets published. NuGet now restores version 4.0.0 as it is an exact match.

  3. Package deletion: Though nuget.org does not allow package deletions, not all package repositories have this constraint. Deletion of a package version results in NuGet finding the best match when it cannot resolve to the deleted version.

  4. Floating versions: When you use floating versions like <PackageReference Include="My.Sample.Lib" Version="4.*"/>, you might get different versions after new versions are available. While the intention here is to float to the latest version on every restore of packages, there are scenarios where users require the graph to be locked to a certain latest version and float to a later version, if available, only upon an explicit gesture.

  5. Package content mismatch: If the same package (id and version) is present with different content across repositories, then NuGet cannot ensure the same package (with the same content hash) gets resolved every time. It also does not warn/error out in such cases. Using the lock file will help you in resolving to the same versions always. External factors would not affect your package graph. In addition, if the lock file changes anytime, you have the ability to find what exactly changed by doing a diff with the previous version. This is particularly helpful when a transitive package version, buried deep into the full package graph, changes because you brought in a new direct dependency.

How to enable the lock file?

To enable the use of lock file with NuGet, set the MSBuild property RestorePackagesWithLockFile in your project file:

<PropertyGroup>
    <RestorePackagesWithLockFile>true</RestorePackagesWithLockFile>
</PropertyGroup>

If this property is set, NuGet restore will generate a lock file – packages.lock.json file at the project root directory. image Note:

  • You must commit/check-in this file in the source code repository so that it is always available for restore.
  • The lock file is a tool (NuGet) generated file and should never be manually edited.
  • Lock file should not be put inside a package. It does not have any significance within a package and will never be used by NuGet.

How does NuGet use the lock file?

NuGet does a quick check to see if there were any changes in the package dependencies as mentioned in the project file (or dependent projects’ files) and if there were no changes, it just restores the packages mentioned in the lock file without re-evaluating the full package graph. If NuGet detects a change in the defined dependencies as enumerated in the project file(s), it re-evaluates the package graph and updates the lock file to reflect the new package graph applicable for the project. This is the default mode and is useful when you are in a development environment actively modifying your package and project dependencies. You can, however, at any point, diff against the previous version of the lock file, if modified, to know the exact dependency changes happening to the package graph. For

Continuous Integration (CI/CD) and other build scenarios, where you would always want the same repeatable restore, you should use the locked mode. You can get into the locked mode by setting the MSBuild property RestoreLockedMode to true:

<span class="nt"><PropertyGroup></span>
       <span class="nt"><RestoreLockedMode</span> <span class="na">Condition=</span><span class="s">"'$(ContinuousIntegrationBuild)' == 'true'"</span><span class="nt">></span>true<span class="nt"></RestoreLockedMode></span>
<span class="nt"></PropertyGroup></span> 

Note: The above example assumes you have a MSBuild property ContinuousIntegrationBuild that is set to true for CI/CD builds. Alternatively, for CI/CD builds, you can use the following command line options to enable locked mode: For dotnet.exe, run:

dotnet.exe restore –locked-mode For msbuild.exe, run:

> msbuild.exe /t:restore /p:RestoreLockedMode=true If 

locked mode is set, restore will either get the exact packages as listed in the lock file or fail if it cannot. For example, if you updated the defined package dependencies for the project after lock file was created or due to any of the reasons mentioned in this post.

SHA validation

In addition to locking the package dependencies graph, NuGet also persists the content hash of all the packages in the lock file. During restore, it verifies that the content hashes match between the lock file and actual restored packages. In case of discrepancy, NuGet restore throws an error. This prevents any inadvertent use of packages with same ID and version but with different content (package content mismatch).

What next?

packages.config

Currently, the lock file feature is only limited to PackageReference based projects. However, the full package closure is already listed in the packages.config file and the only piece missing is content hash of the packages restored. We understand this is an important validation and hence we are working on a similar feature for packages.config. The information in the lock file will have a lot of repetitive contents as in the packages.config file but we plan to keep a consistent lock file experience, as with PackageReference. You can track the progress of this feature, here.

Solution or repo lock file

We believe this feature goes a long way towards addressing the repeatable restore concern that many of you had. However, we are aware that managing multiple project lock files for a huge solution or a repo can be daunting. We have started to think about providing better and easier way to manage package dependencies centrally i.e. at a solution or even a repo level – and thereby providing a central lock file. You can find our early thoughts in the spec: Centrally managing NuGet package versions. We would love to get your early feedback so that we can steer it towards the best experience possible.

We want to hear your feedback!

Please provide any feedback on this feature by commenting on this GitHub issue. If you have any other question, comment or feedback you can reach out to me at anangaur@microsoft.com or tag @nuget in your tweets. You can always create a new issue on our Github repository to start a new discussion or report a bug. To keep yourself updated on all planned NuGet features/experiences, do subscribe to NuGet/Announcements repo. We actively seek participation for all new features and we announce these features on this repo as they get ready for the community review.

Anand Gaurav
Anand Gaurav

Program Manager, Visual Studio and .NET

Follow Anand   

1 comment

Comments are closed.

  • Avatar
    Paul Vrugt (Infoland)

    How does this work if you want to restore package not for a project, but for an entire solution? Is there an option to generate a packages.lock.json for a solution restore? If so, how do i enable this?